Dr Guthrie's Boys School, Liberton. Edinburgh.
This is a photograph of Dr Guthrie's Boys' School in the mid-1960s,
Before the outdoor gymnasium was built.
The place looks grim,
And believe me, it was grim.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________
Here's some old newspaper stories.
Some articles from the British Newspaper Archive that are easy to find on the web.
Kilmarnock Herald and Ayrshire Gazette - Friday 14 November 1947.
Allegations that all was not well at Dr Guthrie's boys' school in Edinburgh were made by Mrs. R. Lambie "Saltcoats" at last month's meeting of the Education Committee, held in the County Buildings on Tuesday.
Mrs. Lambie said there had been frequent escapes from the school and that boys from her district had returned home after escaping, with tales of beatings they had received.
Kilmarnock Herald and North Ayrshire Gazette - Friday 12 December 1947.
Boys at Edinburgh school harshly punished.
The Scotsman - Monday 26 September 1949.
Twenty-seven boys from Dr Guthrie's boys' school escaped last night.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________
An article from the House of Commons Hansard easily found on the web, such as.
Westminster 1950 "MP Mr. Ross.
https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1950/may/02/boys-school-liberton-conditions
Is the hon. Lady aware of the serious state that this school was in about six months ago, as reported in a Committee of this House; that we found the buildings were entirely unsuitable and gloomy,
The children poorly dressed, and the atmosphere oppressive;
And that we thought the best use was not being made of public money?
Will she consider closing the whole thing down?
02 May 1950 vol 474 cc1568-9.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________
In 1854, the House of Commons exposed Dr Guthrie's schools as harsh and oppressive,
And in 1950,
The same House of Commons, exposed the same institution,
For even more violent and harsh practices.
More articles from House of Commons Hansard easy to find on the web, such as.
and again
https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1950/may/02/boys-school-liberton-conditions
Yet the same institution, continues to be portrayed in the Scottish media and now on the internet, as some sort of philanthropic Christian ragged school.
I still remember the staff party when the statue of Dr Guthrie was awarded B status in 1970.
Both my hands were broken at the time.
Children who were detained in Dr Guthrie's schools, which were essentially children's prisons,
Were frequently subjected to sexual abuse, cruelty, and torture.
This abuse was so prevalent, that it was considered normal by the unfortunate children who had the misfortune to be trapped there.
This abuse is completely unknown to the people of Scotland.
Had it not been for the creation of a Facebook group,
A petition on Change.org and then a website by survivors,
This truth would never come to light.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
Another British Newspaper Archive article, easy to find on the web.
The Scotsman - Friday 30 June 1950.
Dr Guthrie's Boys' School responds to criticism in the House of Commons.
A Mr Scott speaking for Dr Guthrie's said, referring to criticism that the buildings were unsuitable, "it's an absolute lie, Dr Guthrie's school at Liberton is one of the brightest schools in Edinburgh" Another spokesperson for Dr Guthrie's, a certain Bailie George Romanes, said the intelligence of the children seems to be below par. Another spokesperson for Dr Guthrie's, the Marquess of Tweeddale, said there was no doubt that boys had been sent to approved schools who were really mental cases. Other speakers included a Mr Charles Guthrie, W.S chairperson of the general committee of the schools and the grandson of the founder of the schools.
"Before Dr Guthrie's, I had an irregular primary education. I received virtually no education after I entered Dr Guthrie's. Today I have some vocational qualifications, but thanks to Dr Guthrie's, I have no educational qualifications.
Although the dysfunction of my family undoubtedly had an impact on my education, I was able to read, write and do well in math before I entered Dr Guthrie's.
I hope that the Scottish authorities, particularly in the child abuse inquiry, are not classifying Dr Guthrie's survivors, like Dr Guthrie's spokespeople, as people of below-par intelligence.
God forbid, they might even classify us as mental cases"
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
I'm not really sure why I was placed in an approved school at the age of eleven. My slight stutter might have been the reason, or perhaps Dr Guthrie's Schools Association was just making money.
I was doing really well at primary school and the teacher was even talking about me going to grammar school. Instead, I ended up at an approved school. I didn't have a school uniform because I came from a poor family, but my mother bought me a new leather school bag just days before I was put away. I didn't commit the crimes I was accused of, and I wasn't allowed to plead not guilty.
In court, they just accused me and basically found me guilty.
I was so small that I could hardly see the judge from the dock. The three crimes of which I was accused, I remember thinking. What are they talking about? At the time, I thought they were putting me away because my father was mentally ill, and I still believe that, but my father was mentally ill because of his experiences in the Second World War. He suffered from PTSD.
My father ended up as a patient at Erskine Military Hospital.
I have never received a secondary school education. My education ended when I was 11. Years ago I did a self-funded correspondence course in networking and computer programming, gaining credits for eight HND and four HNC modules with an average of more than 90%. Although I could have easily continued and gained a degree, all I really wanted to do was prove to myself that I was capable of learning, and I was. I may not have been educated at Dr Guthrie's Boys' School, but I can prove that I am more than capable of learning.
Children who have been abused within the walls of the school,
Have cried so much,
That the building is drenched with horror.
More British Newspaper Archive articles, easy to find on the web.
The escapes continue.....
Edinburgh Evening News - Monday 5th June 1961.
Three boys aged 11, 12 and 13, who escaped from Dr Guthrie's approved school in Edinburgh, were today apprehended in Starbank Road near Newhaven Fish Market.
Edinburgh Evening News - Saturday December 9th 1961.
Two boys from Dr Guthrie's approved school in Liberton, Edinburgh, who went missing at 8 o'clock last night, were apprehended by police in Newington Road a few hours later.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
This is a link to an article from the TES archive.
https://www.tes.com/magazine/archive/soft-teachers-soft-belt
Report from 1969.
Corporal punishment was used in Scotland 10 times as often as in English-approved schools.
Max Paterson wrote to John McPherson, HMI responsible for approved schools, about the true picture of beatings. Punishment books in approved schools did not reflect the actual number of beatings, or that some pupils were held down.
He urged ministers to bring in an immediate ban on belting on the buttocks, which he described as “vicious in the realm of punishment or of attitude”. It also had sexual undertones.
On one visit to another school, I was told by the headmaster, as a 'joke',
That a child, an 11-year old,
Bent over the desk to receive his punishment,
Had soiled himself after two strokes.
The child had panicked, jumped and ran around the room.
The head said:
' You should have seen the job I had before I caught him to give him the rest '.
The school was Dr Guthrie’s Boys’ in Edinburgh.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
Another British Newspaper Archive article, easily found online.
The Scotsman - Wednesday 31st December 1975.
Sadly, the same Max PATERSON mentioned above in the Tes report has been sacked from his job at another 'List D' approved school.
Here's an extract from a letter someone wrote to the paper.
"Do those responsible for, and concerned with children in trouble, really not approve of Max Paterson's views on childcare?
Or are officials, - whether centrally or locally employed -
So muzzled by the form of their office,
That they are unable to speak out?"
Although MPs in the House of Commons called for the Boys' School to close in 1949,
it continued to operate until 1985.
it continued to operate until 1985.
Dr Guthrie's Boys' School was clearly a cruel institution in the 1940s, but it seems that the Scottish elite had more influence than Westminster MPs.
Apparently, all they had to do was to make derogatory remarks about the boys being intellectually challenged and mental cases.
Then they were allowed to abuse the boys for another 35 years, with total impunity.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
The place was as miserable in 1970, as Westminster MPs described it in 1949.
In winter, we wore corduroy shorts and jackets, and all our pockets were sewn up.
Some days, you were literally freezing to death,
And if you dared to put your hands inside your shorts to keep warm,
You would be dragged into the headmaster's office,
Held over his desk,
And belted over your bare bottom.
The toilet in the corner of the square was stinking, and there were no doors to the toilet cubicles,
So you were forced to defecate in front of everyone.
Dr Guthrie's Ragged Schools,
Exclusively for Sadists,
To abuse the Impoverished.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
Given the apparent legal immunity and lack of accountability of Dr Guthrie's Association, 2024 could just as easily be 1854, 1949 or 1950. These people remind me very much of the Catholic Church in the early 1990s, and no one is allowed to voice their displeasure with this institution that supposedly cares for vulnerable and defenceless children.
Were any people arrested for abusing boys between 1947 and 1949? Did anything happen to the voluntary organisation that ran the schools in 1950? Were these people censured, in any way? The fact that the schools were still in existence in 1986, controlled by the same voluntary organisation, leads me to doubt that.
Again, now in 2024, I'm aware that nobody has been arrested, and these people are still getting superstar treatment. They claim they have nothing to do with the schools or the abuse, but they have our records, and we need their permission to access them as survivors.
They have the audacity to donate to charities that support victims of child abuse, but they won't apologise to the survivors of Dr Guthrie's schools. They have the money to donate to child abuse charities, but they have failed to contribute, a single penny, to the Scottish Government's Redress Scheme.
Holding Dr Guthrie's Association accountable seems to be a challenging task. Whether it was Ayrshire Councillors or MPs in the House of Commons calling for the schools to close, their views were deemed irrelevant.
The individuals and organisation, responsible for the vile abuse of children, have not been held to account by the police, the child abuse inquiry or Scottish law.
It is also irrelevant whether or not the survivors have come forward with complaints, some of which describe the most horrific forms of child abuse imaginable.
Consulting a lawyer is also irrelevant.
Why are they above the law?
Statue protest video on YouTube.
Some survivors feel that the inquiry has treated them as second-class citizens. The Inquiry is aware that the average life expectancy of a child who has been in care is only 63 years. However, private fee-paying schools were investigated by the Abuse Inquiry in 2021. Private school pupils tend to live into their mid to late 80s.
We have nothing against private, fee-paying abusive institutions being investigated. I was in favour of investigating these places in a questionnaire I completed years ago, and I am in favour of investigating these places today.
However, in a more compassionate investigation, rather than the final stages of this Scottish abuse inquiry, people with an average life expectancy of just 63 years, would expect the institutions that abused them to be investigated first. Or at least the institutions they complained about would be investigated before expensive fee-paying private schools.
It is because it is so clear that children who have spent time in care have a relatively short life expectancy, that I raise this unethical situation.
At the time of writing, 28th October 2023, they had still not investigated Dr Guthrie's Schools.
'' The child abuse investigation into Dr Guthrie's schools began on 28th May 2024.
The investigation into Dr Guthrie's schools ended on Friday, 21st June 2024.
Not a single Scottish or UK news outlet reported on the abuse.''
We continue to be ignored and disregarded.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________
If you are a former Guthrie boy or the family of a former Guthrie boy
And would like to leave a comment on this page,
Please don't hesitate to contact me using the links.
At the bottom of the home page.
Anonymous comment 1
I was also an inmate at Dr Guthrie's Boys' School and I can assure you all that it was bad.
I broke my right hand playing bulldog there and they told me it was just a bruise, which wasn't true because when I was 18
I had to have the nerves removed from my ring finger and little finger.
At 67 I still have a black spot on my forehead where a teacher stabbed me with a pencil.
I had a teacher who tried to molest me sexually so I kicked him and ran away and was caught by the police and taken back there and called a liar and made to drop my trousers and pants and then beaten with a leather strap.
There is so much more to tell, like my father visited me and I had a blinding headache so I was taken to the matron who put me in the infirmary and later that day
I was forced to have sex with her and in the evening with her assistant.
I was placed there for so-called care and protection, but it was the staff we needed protection from and the reason I was placed there was because of family problems,
so I ran away from home and the children's panel decided that I should be placed there.
As I understand it, Dr Guthries was an approved school, much like a junior prison for bad boys,
but why would I have been placed there for running away from home?
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
Anonymous comment 2
For a so-called Christian institution, they certainly didn't show me any Christian love.
Christmas Eve 1971. I was the only boy left in the school.
I had no home to go to.
I was waiting to be transferred to a remand home.
Everyone had left, except me.
I was watching choirboys on television, then cartoons came on.
The headmaster came and asked me what I was doing,
"I told him I was watching cartoons".
He turned off the TV and told me to find a brush and sweep the square.
Here I am, 13 years old, all alone, sweeping the square. Christmas Eve, stars in the sky, all the lights on in the building. Sweeping the square at 6.00pm on Christmas Eve.
It's very difficult to express the cruelty, barbarism and sadism of the staff towards the boys who simply had the misfortune to be in such a terrible place.
There was a photograph of Baldy on the Internet,
taken around 1978.
He's in a dormitory. He's smiling!
When I saw the photograph in 2007,
it was the first time I had ever seen him smile.
He was a cruel, sadistic bastard.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
Please sign the petition below.
Do not let them get away,
With horrible child abuse.
